Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 24 of 80
An early attempt to find the speed of sound v in a gas assumed that v depends only on the pressure P of the gas and…
Question 245 marksMedium
An early attempt to find the speed of sound v in a gas assumed that v depends only on the pressure P of the gas and its density ρ, in the form v=kPaρb, where k is a dimensionless constant.
(a) Use the method of dimensions to find a and b, and write the resulting relation.
(b) For air, P=1.0×105Pa and ρ=1.3kg m−3. Calculate P/ρ with the correct number of significant figures.
(c) The measured speed of sound in air is 331m s−1. Find the value of k this implies.
(d) Why could the method of dimensions not give the value of k in part (a)?
Both P and ρ are given to two significant figures, so the result is reported as P/ρ=2.8×102m s−1. The value 277 is kept (one extra digit) for use in part (c).
(c)
k=P/ρv=277331=1.19
Since P/ρ is known only to two significant figures, k≈1.2. The constant is clearly not 1: the simple guess v=P/ρ gives a speed about 16% too low.
(d) The method of dimensions only equates powers of M, L and T. A pure number such as k has no dimensions, so it does not appear in these equations and cannot be found from them. Its value must come from experiment, as in part (c), or from a full physical theory of sound.