A research student draws three separate steps from reactions run in her laboratory, using curved arrows.

Which description of the three steps is correct?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 51 of 80
A research student draws three separate steps from reactions run in her laboratory, using curved arrows.

Which description of the three steps is correct?
(A) Steps I and III are homolytic (free-radical) steps; Step II is heterolytic fission giving a carbocation whose positive carbon is sp² hybridised.
(B) Step I is heterolytic fission because two arrows are drawn; Step III is ionic because H–Br is an acid; Step II gives a carbanion.
(C) Steps I and III are homolytic (free-radical) steps; Step II is heterolytic fission giving a carbocation whose positive carbon is sp³ hybridised.
(D) Step I is homolytic; Step II is also homolytic because only one group leaves; Step III is heterolytic because a new H–Br bond forms.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: Read the arrow heads. A fish-hook (single-barbed) arrow moves one electron; a full (double-barbed) arrow moves an electron pair.
Step I: two fish-hook arrows send the two electrons of the Br–Br bond one to each atom. This is homolytic fission, giving two bromine free radicals, Br•.
Step II: one full arrow moves the C–Cl bond pair onto chlorine. This is heterolytic fission: Cl⁻ and the carbocation (CH₃)₃C⁺ are formed. The positive carbon has three σ bonds and no lone pair, so it is sp² hybridised and trigonal planar, with an empty p orbital.
Step III: three fish-hook arrows. One electron of the C–H bond pairs with the odd electron of Br• to make the H–Br bond, and the other electron stays on carbon. Every electron moves singly, so this is a free-radical (homolytic) step, giving the methyl free radical, •CH₃.
(B) Two fish-hook arrows on one bond mean that it breaks evenly (homolysis). Step III makes HBr, but no ions are formed and no electron pair moves. Step II gives a positive carbon, not a carbanion.
(C) correctly identifies the steps but gives the carbocation an sp³ carbon. A carbanion is sp³; a carbocation is sp².
(D) Step II moves an electron pair onto Cl and produces ions, so it is heterolytic. Step III uses only single-electron (fish-hook) arrows, so it is homolytic. Forming a new bond does not make a step heterolytic.