Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: An acid is stronger when its anion (the carboxylate ion, R–COO⁻) is more stable. Chlorine is more electronegative than carbon and withdraws electron density through the σ bonds (−I effect). This spreads out the negative charge of the carboxylate ion and stabilises it, so every chloro acid is stronger than butanoic acid P.
The inductive effect weakens rapidly as the number of intervening bonds increases. In Q the chlorine is on the carbon next to –COOH, in R it is one carbon further away and in S it is two carbons further away. So the stabilisation, and the acid strength, fall in the order Q > R > S, and all three are stronger than P:
Q > R > S > P
- (A) is the reverse order. It treats chlorine as electron-releasing.
- (C) assumes that the farther the chlorine, the stronger its effect, but the inductive effect dies away with distance.
- (D) correctly puts Q first but places P above R and S. Any –Cl on the chain still withdraws some electron density, so R and S remain stronger than P.