For a system to be aromatic it must be planar, the π electrons must be completely delocalised over the ring system, and it must contain (4n + 2) π electrons, where n is a whole number (0, 1, 2, …). Each C=C contributes 2 π electrons.
(I) Anthracene, C₁₄H₁₀: three rings fused in a straight line, with 7 C=C bonds, so 14 π electrons spread over 14 sp² carbons.
4n+2=14⇒n=3
n is a whole number, and the system is planar and fully conjugated, so anthracene is aromatic.
(II) Phenanthrene, C₁₄H₁₀: the same three rings fused at an angle. It also has 7 C=C bonds and 14 π electrons over 14 sp² carbons, so again n = 3 and phenanthrene is aromatic. Changing the way the rings are fused does not change the π-electron count.
(III) Cyclobutadiene, C₄H₄: it has 2 C=C bonds, so 4 π electrons.
4n+2=4⇒n=0.5
n is not a whole number, so even though the ring is cyclic, planar and fully conjugated, cyclobutadiene is not aromatic. Having 4n π electrons (n = 1) makes it highly unstable, which is why it cannot be stored like the two coal-tar hydrocarbons.