Aromatic species must be planar and cyclic, have complete delocalisation of π electrons around the ring, and contain (4n + 2) π electrons, with n = 0, 1, 2, …
(a) (i) Cyclopropenyl cation, C₃H₃⁺: one C=C (2 π electrons), and the carbocation carbon has an empty p orbital (0 electrons), giving 2 π electrons.
4n+2=2⇒n=0
n = 0 is allowed, so the cation is aromatic, which is why it is unusually stable for a carbocation.
(ii) Cyclopropenyl anion, C₃H₃⁻: one C=C (2) plus the lone pair of the carbanion carbon in a p orbital (2), giving 4 π electrons. Then 4n + 2 = 4 gives n = 0.5, not a whole number, so it is not aromatic.
(b) Neutral cyclo-octatetraene has four C=C bonds (8 π electrons), and potassium adds two more electrons. In the structure drawn, this appears as three C=C bonds (6 electrons) plus two carbanion lone pairs (4 electrons). Either way the dianion has 10 π electrons spread over 8 carbons.
4n+2=10⇒n=2
In the flat octagon all eight p orbitals overlap continuously, so the ring is planar, fully delocalised and has (4n + 2) π electrons, and the dianion is aromatic. Neutral cyclo-octatetraene has only 8 π electrons (a 4n number) and avoids planarity by adopting a tub shape.
(c) In (iv) the CH₂ carbon is sp³ and has no p orbital, so the cyclic conjugation is broken, and it has 6 π electrons in three C=C bonds.
- Loss of H⁻: the CH₂ carbon becomes a carbocation with an empty p orbital. The ring C₇H₇⁺ (tropylium ion) is planar and fully conjugated, with 6 π electrons (n = 1). It is aromatic and very stable, so this loss is easy.
- Loss of H⁺: the CH₂ carbon becomes a carbanion whose lone pair joins the π system, giving C₇H₇⁻ with 8 π electrons. This does not fit (4n + 2), so the anion gains no aromatic stability and its formation is unfavourable.