When benzene is chlorinated with Cl₂ and anhydrous FeCl₃, the electrophile Cl⁺ bonds to one ring carbon, which we call C1, to form a carbocation (arenium ion or σ-complex). Which carbons carry the positive charge in the resonance structures of this arenium ion?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 17 of 80
When benzene is chlorinated with Cl₂ and anhydrous FeCl₃, the electrophile Cl⁺ bonds to one ring carbon, which we call…
Question 171 markMCQMedium
Select your answer
- Correct answer
(A) C2, C4 and C6
(B) C3 and C5 only
(C) C1 only
(D) All six carbons equally
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: After Cl⁺ bonds to C1, that carbon becomes sp³ (it carries both H and Cl) and leaves the π system. The remaining five carbons share four π electrons. The positive charge moves through the ring by resonance and sits on the carbon next to C1 (C2), then on C4, then on C6:
These are the positions ortho and para to the carbon that was attacked. When AlCl₄⁻ or FeCl₄⁻ later removes the H⁺ from C1, the aromatic sextet is restored and chlorobenzene forms.
- (B) is wrong: C3 and C5 are meta to C1 and never carry the charge in any resonance structure.
- (C) is wrong: C1 is sp³ and has no p orbital, so it cannot carry the positive charge.
- (D) is wrong: delocalisation stops at the sp³ carbon, so the charge is spread over three carbons, not all six.
