A historian of chemistry tests Kekulé's original benzene structure, a ring of six carbons with fixed alternate single and double bonds, on the dibromotoluenes, C₆H₃Br₂(CH₃). How many isomeric dibromotoluenes does this fixed structure predict, and how many are actually known?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 55 of 80
A historian of chemistry tests Kekulé's original benzene structure, a ring of six carbons with fixed alternate single…
Question 551 markMCQHard
Select your answer
- Correct answer
(A) Ten predicted; six known
(B) Six predicted; six known
(C) Ten predicted; ten known
(D) Twelve predicted; six known
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: Number the CH₃ carbon C1. With equal C–C bonds (the real, resonance-hybrid ring) there are six dibromotoluenes, with Br at 2,3; 2,4; 2,5; 2,6; 3,4 and 3,5.
In a fixed Kekulé ring, an isomer splits into two whenever the bonds between the substituted carbons can be arranged in two non-equivalent ways (C=C in one form where the other has C–C).
- 2,6 and 3,5: these are symmetric about the axis through C1. In both Kekulé forms one side has the C=C and the other the C–C, so the two forms are the same compound, giving 1 each.
- 2,3, 2,4, 2,5 and 3,4: the two Kekulé forms are different compounds, giving 2 each.
Only six are known. All six C–C bonds are identical (139 pm), so the two Kekulé forms are not separate compounds but contributing structures of one resonance hybrid.
- (B) is wrong: six is the real number, which matches the resonance picture, not the fixed-bond structure.
- (C) is wrong: ten is the prediction, but ten isomers have never been found.
- (D) is wrong: twelve assumes that every one of the six isomers doubles, overlooking that the symmetric 2,6- and 3,5-isomers do not.
