A dye plant nitrates five aromatic feedstocks one at a time under identical conditions: methoxybenzene (PhOCH₃), methylbenzene (PhCH₃), benzene (PhH), chlorobenzene (PhCl) and nitrobenzene (PhNO₂). Which order of decreasing rate of nitration is correct?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 50 of 80
A dye plant nitrates five aromatic feedstocks one at a time under identical conditions: methoxybenzene (PhOCH₃)…
- Correct answer
(A) PhOCH₃ > PhCH₃ > PhH > PhCl > PhNO₂
(B) PhOCH₃ > PhCH₃ > PhCl > PhH > PhNO₂
(C) PhCH₃ > PhOCH₃ > PhH > PhCl > PhNO₂
(D) PhNO₂ > PhCl > PhH > PhCH₃ > PhOCH₃
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: The electrophile NO₂⁺ attacks the ring's π electrons, so anything that raises the ring's electron density speeds the reaction up, and anything that lowers it slows the reaction down.
-
–OCH₃ releases electrons strongly by resonance (oxygen lone pairs), which outweighs its –I effect. It is a strongly activating group, so PhOCH₃ is the fastest.
-
–CH₃ releases electrons weakly (+I), so it is mildly activating and PhCH₃ is faster than benzene.
-
–Cl withdraws electrons by its strong –I effect, which outweighs its resonance donation, so it is mildly deactivating and PhCl is slower than benzene.
-
–NO₂ withdraws electrons strongly (–I and resonance), so it is strongly deactivating and PhNO₂ is the slowest.
-
(B) is wrong: it places chlorobenzene above benzene, treating chlorine as activating because it directs ortho/para. Chlorine directs o/p but deactivates the ring.
-
(C) is wrong: it lets the –I effect of oxygen win, making –OCH₃ weaker than –CH₃. For –OCH₃ the resonance donation dominates.
-
(D) is wrong: it is the exact reverse, as if electron-withdrawing groups helped an electrophile.
