(a) Electrostatic attraction increases with the charges on the ions, so on charge alone AlCl₃ (Al³⁺) should have the strongest attraction and the highest melting point, followed by MgCl₂ (Mg²⁺) and then NaCl (Na⁺). The data show the opposite: NaCl melts at 801 °C, MgCl₂ at 714 °C, and AlCl₃ sublimes at only about 180 °C. Charge alone cannot explain the trend.
(b) No ionic bond is completely ionic. A cation distorts (polarises) the electron cloud of the neighbouring Cl⁻ ion and pulls electron density into the region between the nuclei, giving the bond partial covalent character. By Fajans' rules, the polarising power of a cation increases as its charge increases and its size decreases:
| Cation | Charge | Radius / pm | Polarising power |
|---|
| Na⁺ | +1 | 102 | low |
| Mg²⁺ | +2 | 72 | higher |
| Al³⁺ | +3 | 54 | highest |
So covalent character increases from NaCl to MgCl₂ to AlCl₃. NaCl is an essentially ionic lattice with a high melting point. MgCl₂ has some covalent character, so its melting point is lower than expected from its charges. AlCl₃ is largely covalent: on heating, the solid readily breaks up into small neutral Al₂Cl₆ molecules with only weak forces between them, so very little energy is needed and it sublimes at a low temperature.
(c) Molten NaCl contains free Na⁺ and Cl⁻ ions, which move towards the electrodes and carry the current. Liquid AlCl₃ consists mainly of neutral covalent molecules rather than free ions, so there are almost no charge carriers and it conducts very poorly.
(d) AlCl₃ is more likely to dissolve in benzene. Like dissolves like: its largely covalent molecules can mix with a non-polar solvent, whereas MgCl₂ is still mainly ionic, and the strong attractions in its lattice cannot be overcome by a non-polar solvent.