Potassium hydrogen difluoride, KHF₂, is a stable salt used in etching glass. It contains the [F–H···F]⁻ ion, held together by an exceptionally strong hydrogen bond. The corresponding chlorine compound, KHCl₂, does not form under ordinary conditions. Which explanation is correct?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 56 of 80
Potassium hydrogen difluoride, KHF₂, is a stable salt used in etching glass.
(A) Chlorine is more electronegative than fluorine, so the H–Cl bond is too strong to share its hydrogen with a second chloride ion.
(B) In [HF₂]⁻ the two fluorine atoms are joined by an F–F covalent bond, which chlorine atoms cannot form.
- Correct answer
(C) Fluorine is the most electronegative element and F⁻ is very small, so the hydrogen of HF carries a large δ+ charge and is strongly attracted to the concentrated charge of F⁻; the larger Cl⁻ ion, with its charge spread out, forms only a very weak hydrogen bond with HCl.
(D) HCl forms stronger hydrogen bonds than HF, but [HCl₂]⁻ is too large to fit in a crystal with K⁺.
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: The strength of a hydrogen bond X–H···Y depends on how positive the hydrogen is and how concentrated the negative charge on Y is. F is the most electronegative element, so in H–F the shared pair is pulled strongly towards F and H carries a large δ+ charge. F⁻ is the smallest halide ion, so its −1 charge is packed into a tiny volume. The very close approach of the strongly δ+ hydrogen to F⁻ produces the strongest known hydrogen bond, and [F–H···F]⁻ is stable enough to exist in a salt. Cl is less electronegative, so H in HCl is less positive, and Cl⁻ is much larger with its charge spread over a bigger volume. The resulting H···Cl⁻ attraction is too weak for [HCl₂]⁻ to survive in an ordinary salt.
- (A) The electronegativity order is reversed; fluorine (4.0) is more electronegative than chlorine (3.0).
- (B) The ion is held by an H–F covalent bond plus an F···H hydrogen bond; the two F atoms are not bonded to each other.
- (D) HCl forms much weaker hydrogen bonds than HF; the failure is due to weak bonding, not to the size of the crystal.
