Chlorine trifluoride, ClF₃, is so reactive that it is used to clean deposits from the chambers of semiconductor plants. The Cl atom has 3 bond pairs and 2 lone pairs, which point to the five corners of a trigonal bipyramid. Three arrangements are possible: I (both lone pairs axial), II (one lone pair axial and one equatorial) and III (both lone pairs equatorial). Experiments show that ClF₃ adopts arrangement III, which is T-shaped. Counting only the repulsions between electron pairs at 90° (those at 120° and 180° are much weaker), which option gives the correct numbers for arrangement III and the correct reason it is preferred?
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 51 of 80
Chlorine trifluoride, ClF₃, is so reactive that it is used to clean deposits from the chambers of semiconductor plants.
- Correct answer
(A) 0 lone pair–lone pair and 4 lone pair–bond pair repulsions at 90°; III is the only arrangement with neither a 90° lone pair–lone pair repulsion nor as many as six 90° lone pair–bond pair repulsions.
(B) 0 lone pair–lone pair and 6 lone pair–bond pair repulsions at 90°; III is preferred because it has no 90° lone pair–lone pair repulsion.
(C) 1 lone pair–lone pair and 3 lone pair–bond pair repulsions at 90°; III is preferred because it has the fewest lone pair–bond pair repulsions.
(D) 0 lone pair–lone pair and 2 lone pair–bond pair repulsions at 90°; III is preferred because each lone pair is next to only one F atom.
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: In a trigonal bipyramid, an axial position is at 90° to all three equatorial positions, while an equatorial position is at 90° only to the two axial positions. Counting 90° interactions for each arrangement:
| Arrangement | 90° lp–lp | 90° lp–bp |
|---|---|---|
| I (both lp axial) | 0 | 6 (each axial lp is next to 3 equatorial F) |
| II (one axial, one equatorial) | 1 | 3 |
| III (both lp equatorial) | 0 | 4 (each equatorial lp is next to the 2 axial F) |

Repulsion decreases in the order lp–lp > lp–bp > bp–bp. The single 90° lp–lp repulsion in II is the most severe, so II is rejected even though it has the fewest lp–bp repulsions. Between I and III, which both avoid lp–lp at 90°, III has fewer lp–bp repulsions (4 compared with 6). III is therefore the most stable arrangement, and ClF₃ is T-shaped, with the lone pairs also squeezing the F–Cl–F angles slightly below 90°.
- (B) Six lp–bp repulsions belong to arrangement I; an equatorial lone pair has only two neighbours at 90°, not three.
- (C) These are the numbers for arrangement II, and choosing by lp–bp alone ignores the stronger lp–lp repulsion.
- (D) Counts the neighbours of only one lone pair; each of the two equatorial lone pairs is at 90° to both axial F atoms.
