Formal charge and oxidation state are both "electron bookkeeping" numbers, but they are worked out with opposite assumptions about the shared electrons. Oxidation state assigns every shared pair to the more electronegative atom (electronegativity: O > Cl > N > C > H; S < O). Formal charge splits every shared pair equally. Consider the central atom in each of the following species, using the Lewis structure stated:
- N in NH₄⁺ (four N–H bonds)
- O in H₃O⁺ (three O–H bonds, one lone pair)
- C in CH₂Cl₂, the paint-stripper solvent dichloromethane (four single bonds)
- S in SO₄²⁻ (the structure with two S=O and two S–O⁻ bonds)
For which central atom are the formal charge and the oxidation state equal?
