Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 32 of 80
Assertion (A): A solid is formed by mounting a cone of radius r and height h on a hemisphere of the same radius r .
Question 321 markMedium
Assertion (A): A solid is formed by mounting a cone of radius r and height h on a hemisphere of the same radius r. The volume of this solid is 31πr2h+32πr3.
Reason (R): When two solids are joined, the volume of the combination is always less than the sum of their separate volumes, because the faces that come into contact are lost.
(A) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
(B) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
(C) A is true, but R is false
(D) A is false, but R is true
Answer: (C) A is true, but R is false
Looking at the Assertion
The solid is a cone sitting on a hemisphere, so its volume is simply the two volumes added together:
V=Vcone+Vhemisphere=31πr2h+32πr3
That is exactly what the Assertion says, so A is true.
Looking at the Reason
The Reason is false, and this is the point worth remembering.
Think about what "volume" means: it is the amount of space the solid occupies. When you press a cone onto a hemisphere, no material is squeezed away and no space vanishes. Every cubic centimetre of the cone and every cubic centimetre of the hemisphere is still there in the finished solid. So:
volume of the combination=sum of the two volumes, exactlyWhere the Reason's idea really belongs
The Reason has confused volume with surface area. It is the surface area that shrinks:
TSA of the solid=cone’s curved surfaceπrl+hemisphere’s curved surface2πr2
The two flat circles where the solids meet are sealed inside and are no longer part of the outer surface, so the surface area is less than the sum of the two separate total surface areas.
The rule to remember
Volumes add. Surface areas do not.
Your NCERT textbook makes exactly this point at the start of Volume of a Combination of Solids: in surface area we left out the faces that disappeared, but in volume nothing is left out.