Option (D) is correct.
Concept used — surface area and volume of a combination
When two solids are joined along a flat face, the two faces that touch are sealed inside, so the surface area of the combination is the sum of the surfaces that can still be seen:
TSA of combination=sum of the visible (outer) surfaces
Volumes simply add, because no material is lost in joining.
Let the common radius be r and the slant height of the cone be l.
Step 1 — Check the Assertion. Separately, the two solids have
TSA of hemisphere=2πr2+πr2=3πr2,TSA of cone=πrl+πr2
Sum of the separate TSAs=3πr2+πrl+πr2=4πr2+πrl
After joining, the flat face of the hemisphere and the base of the cone are glued together and hidden. Only the two curved surfaces remain:
TSA of the solid=2πr2+πrl
(4πr2+πrl)−(2πr2+πrl)=2πr2
The solid has 2πr2 less surface (the two hidden circles of area πr2 each) than the sum of the separate TSAs. A is false.
Step 2 — Check the Reason. The faces that come into contact are inside the solid and cannot be seen, so they are not part of its surface. R is true.
Step 3 — Choose the option. A is false and R is true, which is option (D). (R is in fact the reason A fails.)
Answer: (D) A is false, but R is true.