Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 67 of 80
In Activity 4.8, 1 mL of ethanol, 1 mL of glacial acetic acid and a few drops of concentrated sulphuric acid are taken…
Question 671 markMCQHard
In Activity 4.8, 1 mL of ethanol, 1 mL of glacial acetic acid and a few drops of concentrated sulphuric acid are taken in a test tube and warmed in a water bath. A student keeps the water bath at about 360 K for five minutes and then finds that only a weak sweet smell is produced.
Substance
Boiling point (K)
Acetic acid
391
Ethanol
351
Water
373
Concentrated sulphuric acid
above 500
Using the data, which option correctly explains the weak smell and states what the student should change?
Select your answer
(A) Acetic acid boils off at 360 K, so too little acid is left to form the ester; the bath should be kept above 391 K.
(B) Ethanol boils off at 360 K, so too little alcohol is left to react with the acid; the bath should be kept below 351 K.
Correct answer
(C) The water formed in the reaction boils off at 360 K and carries the ester away with it; the bath should be kept below 373 K.
(D) The sulphuric acid boils off at 360 K, so no catalyst is left; more sulphuric acid should be added during heating.
Option (B) is correct.
Explanation: This needs two steps: find what escapes, then link it to the amount of ester.
Step 1, what escapes. A liquid boils away when it is heated above its boiling point. Compare each boiling point with the bath at about 360 K:
Substance
Boiling point (K)
Above or below 360 K?
Ethanol
351
below: it boils at 360 K
Water
373
above
Acetic acid
391
above
Conc. sulphuric acid
above 500
far above
Only ethanol boils at the bath temperature, so it is the substance lost as vapour.
Step 2, effect on the ester. The ester is formed from the acid and the alcohol:
CH3COOH+CH3CH2OHacidCH3COOCH2CH3+H2O
Every molecule of ethanol that boils away is a molecule that can no longer react, so less ester forms and the sweet smell is weak. Keeping the bath below 351 K (warm, not boiling) keeps the ethanol in the tube long enough to react; this is why the book says to warm in a water bath rather than heat strongly.
Option (A) is wrong: acetic acid boils at 391 K, above the bath temperature, so it does not boil off; heating above 391 K would drive off the ethanol even faster.
Option (C) is wrong: water boils at 373 K, above the bath temperature, and the problem is a reactant being lost, not the product.
Option (D) is wrong: concentrated sulphuric acid boils far above 500 K, so it stays in the tube as the catalyst.