Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Two drawings show the same compound if the carbon atoms are joined in the same way, however the chain is turned or bent on paper. So compare how each carbon is connected, not the shape of the drawing.
Step 1: check every drawing is C5H12. Each skeleton has 5 carbon atoms and 4 C–C bonds and no ring. Count the hydrogen atoms carbon by carbon: a carbon with 1 carbon neighbour carries 3 H, with 2 neighbours 2 H, with 3 neighbours 1 H, and with 4 neighbours none.
| Drawing | Carbons with 1, 2, 3, 4 C neighbours | H atoms | Formula |
|---|
| (i) five in a row | 2, 3, 0, 0 | 2×3+3×2=12 | C5H12 |
| (ii) four in a row, branch on the 2nd carbon | 3, 1, 1, 0 | 3×3+1×2+1×1=12 | C5H12 |
| (iii) four in a row, branch on the 3rd carbon | 3, 1, 1, 0 | 12 | C5H12 |
| (iv) three in a row, two branches on the middle carbon | 4, 0, 0, 1 | 4×3=12 | C5H12 |
| (v) five in a row, bent | 2, 3, 0, 0 | 12 | C5H12 |
Each has 5+12=17 atoms joined by 16 covalent bonds (4 C–C and 12 C–H).
Step 2: find the hidden duplicates.
- (v) is (i) drawn with a bend. Bonds can be drawn at any angle; the atoms are still joined in one unbranched chain of five, so it is the same compound.
- (iii) is (ii) read from the other end. In a chain of four carbons, the 3rd carbon from one end is the 2nd from the other end, so a branch on "carbon 3" is a branch on "carbon 2". Same compound.
- (i), (ii) and (iv) differ in connection: no branch; one branch; two branches on one carbon.
So the five drawings show three different compounds, which is the number of structural isomers of pentane.
Option (A) is wrong: it counts drawings, not compounds; (iii) repeats (ii) and (v) repeats (i).
Option (B) is wrong: it spots only one of the two duplicates.
Option (C) is wrong: it treats (iv) as the same as (ii), but (iv) has two branches on one carbon and a chain of only three, so its carbons are joined differently.
