Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Read the two observations as two separate tests on two separate portions of the gas.
What the bromine water removed. The colour fades because bromine is used up in an addition reaction across a carbon–carbon double or triple bond. The added product is no longer a gas, so the gas volume falls. So the original gas contained an unsaturated hydrocarbon, for example:
CH2=CH2+Br2→CH2Br−CH2Br
What passed through. The gas left over does not decolourise fresh bromine water, so it has no multiple bond. It burns with a clean blue flame, which is how saturated hydrocarbons burn. So it is a saturated hydrocarbon such as methane:
CH4+2O2→CO2+2H2O
Since part of the gas was absorbed and part was not, the cylinder held a mixture of the two kinds.
Option (A) is wrong: a saturated hydrocarbon does not react with bromine water, so it cannot account for the colour fading and the large loss of gas.
Option (B) is wrong: excess bromine water would absorb all of a single unsaturated gas; and the gas that came through no longer reacts with bromine, so it cannot be the same unsaturated compound.
Option (C) is wrong: both ethene and ethyne are unsaturated and both add bromine, so neither would pass through unchanged, and neither burns with a clean blue flame.
