A student writes down what she believes are the first members of four different homologous series:
- methanol
- methanal
- methanone
- methanoic acid
One of these four compounds cannot exist. Which one, and why?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 50 of 80
A student writes down what she believes are the first members of four different homologous series:
One of these four compounds cannot exist. Which one, and why?
(A) Methanol — an alcohol needs at least two carbon atoms, so the series begins at ethanol.
(B) Methanal — an aldehyde must have a carbon atom on each side of the group.
(C) Methanone — a ketone needs a carbon atom on both sides of its group, so the smallest possible ketone has three carbon atoms.
(D) Methanoic acid — a carboxylic acid needs a group attached to , so the series begins at ethanoic acid.
Option (C) is correct.
Explanation: In a ketone the group lies inside the chain, with a carbon atom on each side of it:
That needs at least three carbon atoms: one for the and one on either side. So the ketone series starts at propanone, , and "methanone" cannot exist: a one-carbon ketone would have nothing on either side of its carbonyl group.
The other three are real and are the first members of their series:
| Name | Formula | Series |
|---|---|---|
| Methanol | alcohols | |
| Methanal | aldehydes | |
| Methanoic acid | carboxylic acids |
In each of these the functional group sits at the end of the chain, where a hydrogen atom can fill the position a second carbon would occupy: methanal is and methanoic acid is . A ketone group cannot do this because it must be in the middle.
Option (A) is wrong: methanol, , exists; an group can be attached to a single carbon atom.
Option (B) is wrong: methanal, , exists; the group is at the end of a chain and its carbon needs no carbon neighbour.
Option (D) is wrong: methanoic acid, , exists; the group does not need a group attached to it.

The functional groups and the series each one names, with a worked example of every class.