(a) The caretaker's observations show that water speeds up rusting, but they do not show that water is enough on its own. The wet bottom bar is also in contact with air the whole time. Activity 3.14 separates the two:
- Tube A, nail in water in a corked tube, with air above the water and dissolved in it (air and water): the nail rusts.
- Tube B, nail in boiled water under oil (water but no air): no rust.
- Tube C, nail in air dried by anhydrous calcium chloride (air but no water): no rust.
Tube B shows that water without air does not cause rusting. So iron rusts only when both air (oxygen) and water are present; on the gate, the wet bar rusts fastest because it has both.
(b) Both work as a physical barrier: a continuous film of paint or oil keeps air and moisture from reaching the iron surface.
Their shared weakness is that the protection lasts only as long as the film is unbroken. Where the gate is scratched, chipped or worn, air and water reach the iron at that spot and rusting starts there; and once it starts under the paint, it spreads sideways and lifts the film off. (Oil has the further weakness that rain washes it off, so it must be applied again and again.)
(c) The mass increases.
Rust forms when iron combines with the oxygen of the air in the presence of water. Nothing leaves the bar during rusting: every iron atom is still there, now combined with oxygen (and water) taken in from the air. Since matter is added, and none of the rust has been lost,
mass of rusted bar=mass of iron+mass of oxygen and water taken up
so the rusted bar is heavier than the original iron. It only looks as if metal has been lost because, in real life, rust is brown and flaky and falls away from the iron; here it was kept, so the gain in mass shows.

Activity 3.14: rust forms only where air and water are both present.