Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Apply the conditions one at a time.
- It must be a solid in use. Mercury melts at −39 °C, so it is a liquid at room temperature. Lead melts at 327 °C, so the end of the insert near the tip (340 °C) would melt. Both are ruled out, even though they have the two lowest conductivities.
- Of the metals that stay solid at 340 °C, choose the poorest conductor of heat, so that the least heat reaches the hand. That leaves silver (429) and aluminium (237). Aluminium conducts heat only about half as well as silver (237 against 429).
So aluminium is the best choice. (Silver and copper are the best conductors of heat, and lead and mercury are comparatively poor conductors; but a poor conductor is no use here if it melts.)
Option (A) is wrong: silver has the highest thermal conductivity in the table, so it would carry heat to the hand fastest.
Option (B) is wrong: lead has the lowest conductivity of the solids, but its melting point (327 °C) is below the 340 °C reached near the tip, so the insert would melt.
Option (C) is wrong: mercury is a liquid at room temperature, so it cannot be a solid insert at all.
