Four beakers each hold 50 mL of the same dilute hydrochloric acid, and a pH meter reads pH 1 in every beaker. One of the following is added to each beaker and stirred in, and the pH is read again.
In which beaker does the pH reading stay the same?
Confirming your payment
Competency-Based Questions (CBQ) · Question 45 of 80
Four beakers each hold 50 mL of the same dilute hydrochloric acid, and a pH meter reads pH 1 in every beaker. One of the following is added to each beaker and stirred in, and the pH is read again.
In which beaker does the pH reading stay the same?
(A) A few crystals of sodium chloride
(B) 50 mL of distilled water
(C) A spatula-full of sodium carbonate
(D) A small piece of magnesium ribbon
Option (A) is correct.
Explanation: The pH of the acid is fixed by the concentration of ions in it, that is, how many ions there are in each millilitre. So the question to ask of each addition is: does it remove ions, or spread them through more liquid?
Sodium chloride does neither. It is the salt of a strong acid () and a strong base (), so it is a neutral salt: its and ions do not react with ions, and a few crystals hardly change the volume. The number of ions per millilitre is unchanged, so the pH stays at 1.
The three other additions all raise the pH, each for a different reason, which is what makes this a trap:
| Added | What happens to the ions | pH |
|---|---|---|
| Distilled water | the same number of ions is spread through twice the volume (dilution) | rises |
| Sodium carbonate | they are used up: | rises |
| Magnesium ribbon | they are used up: | rises |
Option (B) is wrong: water is neutral, but adding it is not neutral in effect. It dilutes the acid, so there are fewer ions in each millilitre and the pH rises (towards 7, though it never passes 7).
Option (C) is wrong: sodium carbonate is a basic salt, and it reacts with the acid, removing ions as carbon dioxide and water, so the pH rises.
Option (D) is wrong: magnesium is not a base, yet it still removes ions, turning them into hydrogen gas, so fewer ions remain in each millilitre and the pH rises.
