A laboratory assistant finds three unlabelled jars, P, Q and R. The labels that fell off them read: zinc granules, magnesium turnings, copper(II) oxide, anhydrous sodium carbonate and sodium chloride, so two of the labels belong to other jars. He tests a little of each solid.
| Test | Jar P: silvery-grey turnings | Jar Q: black powder | Jar R: white powder |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dilute hydrochloric acid added | fizzes; the gas burns with a pop | no gas; the powder slowly dissolves and the solution turns blue-green | fizzes; the gas turns lime water milky |
| Sodium hydroxide solution added and warmed | no reaction | no reaction | dissolves; no gas |
| Shaken with water, then tested with red litmus | no change | does not dissolve; no change | dissolves; red litmus turns blue |
(a) Identify P, Q and R. For each, state the observation that rules out the other label it could most easily be confused with. [2]
(b) Write balanced chemical equations, with state symbols, for the reaction of each of P, Q and R with dilute hydrochloric acid. [2]
(c) The assistant says: "All three solids reacted with the acid and gave a salt, so all three must be bases." Explain whether he is right for each of P, Q and R. [1]

