(a) Sort the five into groups first, then tell the members of each group apart.
- Acidic (blue litmus turns red, phenolphthalein colourless): P and T.
- Basic (phenolphthalein pink, blue litmus unchanged): R and S.
- Neutral (pH 7, no indicator changes): Q.
| Solution | Identity | Reasoning |
|---|
| P | dilute HCl | pH 1, the most acidic, and the only one that fizzes vigorously with marble, as only an acid with plenty of H+ ions does: CaCO3+2HCl→CaCl2+H2O+CO2 |
| T | NH4Cl solution | Acidic but only mildly (pH 5): the salt of a strong acid (HCl) and a weak base (NH4OH). It has too few H+ ions to make marble fizz visibly. |
| R | dilute NaOH | Basic, but with dilute HCl it gives no gas: it is simply neutralised, NaOH+HCl→NaCl+H2O, so it is an alkali and not a carbonate. A base does not react with marble. |
| S | Na2CO3 solution | It fizzes with dilute HCl and the gas turns lime water milky, so it gives carbon dioxide and must be a carbonate: Na2CO3+2HCl→2NaCl+H2O+CO2. It is basic because it is the salt of a weak acid (H2CO3) and a strong base (NaOH). |
| Q | distilled water | pH 7, no change with any indicator, no reaction with marble. |
Notice that litmus and phenolphthalein alone can only split the five into three groups. The pH values and the marble test separate the strong acid from the acidic salt. The two basic solutions are told apart by the dilute HCl test, not by their pH: a pH reading depends on how concentrated a solution is, so pH 13 against pH 12 alone could not prove which is the alkali, but only a carbonate fizzes with acid.
(b)
HCl(aq)+NaOH(aq)→NaCl(aq)+H2O(l)
The neutral mixture is a solution of sodium chloride, a salt of a strong acid and a strong base, so its pH is 7, just like Q. But it contains a large number of Na+ and Cl− ions, free to move, and these carry the current, so the bulb glows brightly. Distilled water (Q) contains very few ions, so it hardly conducts. Two liquids can have the same pH and still be very different: pH tells you only about the balance of H+ and OH− ions, not about the other ions present.