(a) Tube A contained hydrochloric acid. Its curve rises much more steeply: it collects almost all of its 120 mL within about 2 minutes, whereas tube B takes about 20 minutes to reach the same volume. Hydrogen is given off much faster in A.
Mg(s)+2HCl(aq)→MgCl2(aq)+H2(g)
(b) Magnesium reacts with the H+ ions in the acid, so the more H+ ions there are in the solution, the faster hydrogen is produced.
- Hydrochloric acid is a strong acid: it is completely ionised in water, so its solution is full of H+ ions and the reaction is fast.
- Acetic acid is a weak acid: at the same concentration, only a small fraction of its molecules is ionised at any moment, so there are far fewer H+ ions and the reaction is much slower.
(c) Both tubes contained the same amount of acid: 10 mL of a 1 M solution. Since magnesium was in excess, the volume of hydrogen at the end is decided only by how much acid there was, so both give the same 120 mL.
The point to see is that "weak" does not mean "less acid". The acetic acid molecules that are not ionised at the start are not lost. As the magnesium uses up the few H+ ions present, more acetic acid molecules ionise to replace them, and this continues until all the acid has reacted. A weak acid releases its H+ ions a few at a time instead of all at once, so it reacts more slowly, but in the end it reacts just as completely.
(d)
| Test | Hydrochloric acid | Acetic acid |
|---|
| Universal indicator | red: pH about 0 to 1 | orange: pH about 2 to 3 |
| Conductivity tester | bulb glows brightly | bulb glows only dimly |
Both results follow from the same fact. Hydrochloric acid, being fully ionised, has many more H+ ions (a lower pH) and many more ions in total to carry the current (a brighter bulb) than acetic acid of the same concentration.

Strength is how completely an acid ionises. It is not the same thing as concentration.