Write the shortcomings of Rutherford atomic model. Explain how these were overcome by the postulates of Bohr's atomic model.
OR
Write two important limitations of Rutherford's nuclear model of the atom.
Confirming your payment
Previous Year Questions · Question 24 of 37
Write the shortcomings of Rutherford atomic model. Explain how these were overcome by the postulates of Bohr's atomic model.
OR
Write two important limitations of Rutherford's nuclear model of the atom.
Shortcomings of Rutherford's model
Instability. An electron revolving round the nucleus is accelerated (centripetal acceleration). According to classical electromagnetic theory an accelerated charge radiates energy, so the electron should lose energy, spiral inwards and fall into the nucleus. Real atoms are stable.
Line spectra. As the electron spirals in, its frequency of revolution would change continuously, so it would emit a continuous spectrum. Atoms actually emit line spectra.
How Bohr's postulates overcome them
First postulate: an electron can revolve in certain stable (stationary) orbits without emitting radiation. This makes the atom stable.
Second postulate: the stationary orbits are those for which the angular momentum is an integral multiple of :
So only certain orbits, with definite energies, are allowed.
Since the energies are discrete, only certain frequencies are emitted, giving a line spectrum.
| Rutherford model | Bohr model improvement |
|---|---|
| Electrons accelerate and should radiate, so the atom is unstable | Electrons in stationary orbits do not radiate, so the atom is stable |
| Cannot explain line spectra (predicts a continuous spectrum) | Discrete energy levels, with emission or absorption of photons, explain line spectra |
OR: the two limitations of Rutherford's model are the two shortcomings above: it cannot explain the stability of the atom, and it cannot explain the line spectrum of atoms.