Before the parts, read the definition once more: a pair (V1,V2) belongs to R only if both named citizens actually used their voting right. Write S for the set of eligible citizens who did vote, so that
R=S×S,S⊆I.
The passage tells us turnout was about 67%, so S is a proper subset of I — roughly a third of the eligible citizens did not vote. That single fact settles part 4.
1) Option (D) is correct.
X voted but Y did not, so Y∈/S.
- (A) (X,Y)∈R would need both X and Y to have voted. Y did not, so this is false.
- (B) (Y,X)∈R fails for the same reason — the condition asks about both members of the pair, whichever order they are written in.
- (C) (X,X)∈/R is false: X did vote, so both members of the pair (X,X) voted and (X,X)∈R.
- (D) (X,Y)∈/R is true, by the reasoning in (A).
So the answer to part 1 is (D).
2) Option (A) is correct.
Both X and W voted, so X∈S and W∈S. In the pair (X,W) both members voted, so (X,W)∈R; in the pair (W,X) both members voted as well, so (W,X)∈R. Both ordered pairs qualify, which is exactly option (A). Options (B), (C) and (D) each claim one of the two pairs is missing, and none is.
3) Option (A) is correct.
All three friends voted, so F1,F2,F3∈S. Any ordered pair drawn from these three has both members in S, so every such pair lies in R — including (F1,F2), (F2,F3) and, in particular, (F3,F1). Option (A) is the only one that puts all three pairs in R.
4) Option (A) is correct: R is symmetric and transitive but not reflexive.
Test the three properties of R on I.
Not reflexive. Reflexivity would need (Z,Z)∈R for every eligible citizen Z∈I. Turnout was about 67%, so there is certainly some eligible citizen Z who did not vote, i.e. Z∈/S. For that Z the pair (Z,Z) fails the condition, so (Z,Z)∈/R and R is not reflexive.
Symmetric. Suppose (V1,V2)∈R. Then V1 and V2 both voted. The same two citizens both voted when named in the other order, so (V2,V1)∈R. Hence R is symmetric.
Transitive. Suppose (V1,V2)∈R and (V2,V3)∈R. From the first pair V1∈S; from the second pair V3∈S. So both members of (V1,V3) voted and (V1,V3)∈R. Hence R is transitive.

That is option (A). The others fail:
- (B) Universal relation would mean R=I×I, every pair of eligible citizens related. It is not: any pair containing a non-voter is absent.
- (C) Equivalence relation requires all three properties, and reflexivity fails.
- (D) is wrong twice over — R is not reflexive, and it is symmetric and transitive.
Part 3 is a useful contrast here: restricted to the three friends {F1,F2,F3}, who all voted, R does contain every ordered pair and so behaves like an equivalence relation on that small set. But part 4 asks about the relation R as the passage defines it, on the whole of I, and there the non-voters break reflexivity.