(i) Give a chemical test to distinguish between N-methylethanamine and N,N-dimethylethanamine.
Question 273 marksAsked 2020Hard
(i) Give a chemical test to distinguish between N-methylethanamine and N,N-dimethylethanamine.
(ii) Write the reaction for catalytic reduction of nitrobenzene followed by reaction of the product so formed with bromine water.
(iii) Out of butan-1-ol and butan-1-amine, which will be more soluble in water and why?
(i) Hinsberg test. Shake each amine with benzenesulphonyl chloride (C6H5SO2Cl) and aqueous NaOH.
N-Methylethanamine (CH3NHC2H5) is a secondary amine. It reacts to give N-ethyl-N-methylbenzenesulphonamide, a solid that is insoluble in NaOH (no H on nitrogen, so it is not acidic):
N,N-Dimethylethanamine ((CH3)2NC2H5) is a tertiary amine with no N–H hydrogen, so it does not react and no sulphonamide forms.
(ii) Catalytic reduction gives aniline. Aniline with bromine water at room temperature gives a white precipitate of 2,4,6-tribromoaniline, because –NH2 strongly activates all the ortho and para positions:
C6H5NO2+3H2Pd or NiC6H5NH2+2H2O
C6H5NH2+3Br2H2OC6H2Br3NH2+3HBr
(iii) Butan-1-ol is more soluble in water (the answer NCERT expects from this question in the text). Both compounds dissolve by forming hydrogen bonds with water, and both have the same four-carbon hydrophobic chain, so the difference comes from the polar group. NCERT takes the electronegativity of oxygen as 3.5 and of nitrogen as 3.0. The O–H bond of the alcohol is therefore more polar than the N–H bond of the amine: alcohols are more polar than amines and form stronger hydrogen bonds. Stronger hydrogen bonding with water makes butan-1-ol the more soluble of the two.
(Note: this is the reasoning expected in the board examination. Measured data do not fully follow it. Butan-1-amine mixes with water in all proportions, because the lone pair on nitrogen is a good hydrogen-bond acceptor for the O–H of water. Write the NCERT answer above in the examination.)