Explain why:
(i) Carboxyl group in benzoic acid is meta directing.
(ii) Sodium bisulphite is used for the purification of aldehydes and ketones.
(iii) Carboxylic acids do not give characteristic reactions of carbonyl group.
Confirming your payment
Previous Year Questions · Question 27 of 37
Explain why:
(i) Carboxyl group in benzoic acid is meta directing.
(ii) Sodium bisulphite is used for the purification of aldehydes and ketones.
(iii) Carboxylic acids do not give characteristic reactions of carbonyl group.
(i) The –COOH group withdraws electrons from the benzene ring by resonance (and by induction). In the resonance structures the ring π electrons move towards the carboxyl group, and a positive charge appears at the two ortho positions and the para position, never at the meta positions.

So the ring is deactivated as a whole, but the ortho and para positions are the most electron-poor. The meta positions are relatively richer in electrons, and an electrophile attacks there. Hence –COOH is deactivating and meta directing.
(ii) Sodium hydrogensulphite () adds to aldehydes (and to small, unhindered ketones such as methyl ketones) to form a hydrogensulphite addition compound, which is water soluble. Impurities that are not carbonyl compounds do not react and can be separated from it. The addition is reversible: treating the adduct with dilute mineral acid or alkali gives back the pure aldehyde or ketone.

(iii) In a carboxylic acid the carbonyl carbon is attached to an –OH group. A lone pair on this oxygen is delocalised into the C=O group by resonance. This reduces the partial positive charge on the carbonyl carbon, so it is much less electrophilic than the carbonyl carbon of an aldehyde or ketone. As a result, carboxylic acids do not give nucleophilic addition reactions such as those with HCN, or the ammonia derivatives (2,4-DNP, hydroxylamine).
