A Grignard reagent adds its alkyl group to the carbon of a C=O group; hydrolysis then gives an alcohol in which the former carbonyl carbon carries the new alkyl group and the –OH.
(a) P + CH3 gives C2H6O (ethanol, CH3CH2OH), so P has one carbon and is an aldehyde: P = methanal, HCHO.
(b) C3H6O carbonyl isomers are propanal (CH3CH2CHO) and propanone (CH3COCH3). Q gives no silver mirror, so it is not an aldehyde: Q = propanone, and R = propanal.
- From Q: 2-methylpropan-2-ol, (CH3)3COH (tertiary).
- From R: butan-2-ol, CH3CH2CH(OH)CH3 (secondary).
(c) Primary alcohol (from P):
HCHO+CH3MgBr→CH3CH2OMgBr
CH3CH2OMgBr+H2O→CH3CH2OH+Mg(OH)Br
Tertiary alcohol (from Q):
CH3COCH3+CH3MgBr→(CH3)3COMgBr
(CH3)3COMgBr+H2O→(CH3)3COH+Mg(OH)Br

(d) The mechanism is nucleophilic addition to the carbonyl group. The C–Mg bond is polar (Cδ−H3–Mgδ+Br), so the methyl group acts as a nucleophile and attacks the electron-poor carbonyl carbon of propanal; the C=O π electrons move onto oxygen, which bonds to MgBr. Hydrolysis then gives the secondary alcohol:
CH3CH2CHO+CH3MgBr→CH3CH2CH(CH3)OMgBr
CH3CH2CH(CH3)OMgBr+H2O→CH3CH2CH(OH)CH3+Mg(OH)Br