In a class test, the mean score of the class is 60. Half the students of the class scored 80 marks or above in the test. Dipti said, "Each of the remaining half of the students would have definitely got 40 marks or below in the test for the mean to be 60 marks". Prove or disprove Dipti's statement with a valid example.
Previous Year Questions · Question 23 of 42
In a class test, the mean score of the class is 60.
Dipti's statement is not correct.
A mean of 60 only fixes the total of all the scores. It says nothing about how the remaining half of the class is spread out — those students can score anything at all, as long as the total works out.
Counter-example. Take a class of 4 students with scores
The mean is:
Half the class (2 students) scored 80 or above, exactly as the question states.
But of the remaining two students, one scored 50, which is above 40. Dipti claimed every student in that remaining half must have scored 40 or below, and this single example shows that is false — the low score of 20 balances the high score of 50 and the mean still comes out to 60.
Hence Dipti's statement is disproved.
