(i) Rows: 11+20+14=45. Columns: 14+18+13=45. This must happen because every number from 1 to 9 is in exactly one row (and in exactly one column), and 1+2+⋯+9=45. All six circled numbers add up to 45+45=90.
(ii) Call the squares by their place (top-left, top-middle, and so on).
- Top row: top-left+8+top-right=11, so top-left + top-right = 3. The only two different numbers adding up to 3 are 1 and 2.
- Right column: top-right+middle-right+5=13, so top-right + middle-right = 8.
- Bottom row: bottom-left+bottom-middle+5=14, so bottom-left + bottom-middle = 9.
- Middle column: 8+middle+bottom-middle=18, so middle + bottom-middle = 10.
Try top-right = 2. Then top-left = 1 and middle-right = 6. The numbers left are 3, 4, 7 and 9, and no two of them add up to 9 for the bottom row. So this does not work.
So top-right = 1, top-left = 2 and middle-right = 7. The numbers left are 3, 4, 6 and 9. For the bottom row, the pair adding up to 9 is 3 and 6. For the middle column, middle + bottom-middle = 10, so bottom-middle = 6 and middle = 4 (with 3, the middle would have to be 7, which is already used). Then bottom-left = 3, and the last number, 9, goes in the middle-left square.
| Left | Middle | Right |
|---|
| Top row | 2 | 8 | 1 |
| Middle row | 9 | 4 | 7 |
| Bottom row | 3 | 6 | 5 |
Check: rows 2+8+1=11, 9+4+7=20, 3+6+5=14; columns 2+9+3=14, 8+4+6=18, 1+7+5=13.
(iii) The three column sums must add up to 45, as in part (i). But 14+18+14=46, not 45. So the misprinted card cannot be solved.