(i) All the tokens together add up to
4+5+6+7+8+9+10+11+12=72
The three rows use every token exactly once, so the three row sums add up to 72. The three row sums are equal, so the magic sum is 72÷3=24.
(ii) The tokens are 9 consecutive numbers. In the generalised form of a 3 × 3 magic square, the centre is m and the magic sum is 3m. Here 3m=24, so m=8. The token 8 goes in the centre (it is also the middle number of 4 to 12).
(iii) Fill one line at a time, each time using a line that has only one empty square:
- Top row: 11+4+top-right=24, so top-right = 9.
- Diagonal from the top-left: 11+8+bottom-right=24, so bottom-right = 5.
- Middle column: 4+8+bottom-middle=24, so bottom-middle = 12.
- Bottom row: bottom-left+12+5=24, so bottom-left = 7.
- Left column: 11+middle-left+7=24, so middle-left = 6.
- Right column: 9+middle-right+5=24, so middle-right = 10.
| Left | Middle | Right |
|---|
| Top row | 11 | 4 | 9 |
| Middle row | 6 | 8 | 10 |
| Bottom row | 7 | 12 | 5 |
Check the lines not used yet: middle row 6+8+10=24 and the other diagonal 9+8+7=24. Every token from 4 to 12 is used exactly once.
(iv) A corner square lies on three lines: a row, a column and a diagonal, and these three lines share only the corner square. If 4 were in a corner, each of these three lines would need two other tokens adding up to 24−4=20, and the three pairs would all be different tokens.
From the tokens 5 to 12, the only pairs adding up to 20 are 8+12 and 9+11 (10+10 would need the token 10 twice). That is only two pairs, but three are needed. So 4 can never be in a corner.