(i) The HCF is a factor of both numbers, and both numbers are factors of the LCM. So the HCF must be a factor of the LCM.
But 60÷8 gives 7 with remainder 4, so 8 is not a factor of 60. (Put another way: if both numbers were multiples of 8, every common multiple, including the LCM, would be a multiple of 8, and 60 is not.) So an HCF of 8 and an LCM of 60 cannot go together, and Ravi has made a mistake.
(ii) Both numbers are multiples of 4, so write them as 4×a and 4×b, where a and b have no common factor other than 1 (otherwise the HCF would be bigger than 4). Their LCM is then 4×a×b, so
4×a×b=60,a×b=15
a=1,b=15 gives 4 and 60; a=3,b=5 gives 12 and 20.
Check 12 and 20:
12=2×2×3,20=2×2×5
HCF =2×2=4 and LCM =2×2×3×5=60.
HCF×LCM=4×60=240,12×20=240
The two results are equal, as expected.