For her science fair, Hetal wants to get salt from one cup of salty water as quickly as possible. She will keep it on the sunny terrace. She can pour it into a tall, deep steel glass or into a wide, flat steel thali. Which should she choose, and why?
Practice Questions · Question 5 of 20
For her science fair, Hetal wants to get salt from one cup of salty water as quickly as possible.
(A) The deep glass, because the salt settles at the bottom of deep water and can then be scooped out
(B) The deep glass, because its high sides stop the wind from blowing the salt away
(C) The wide thali, because the steel of the thali soaks up the water
- Correct answer
(D) The wide thali, because the water spreads thin and more of it faces the sun and air
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation:
The salt is dissolved in the water, so Hetal must let the water evaporate. In the thali the same cup of water spreads out in a thin layer, so much more of it is open to the sun and air than in the glass. You learnt in 'A Journey through States of Water' that water spread over a larger area evaporates faster, so the thali dries first and leaves the salt behind.
This is also why seawater is kept in shallow pits exposed to sunlight and air to obtain salt: in a few days the water evaporates completely, leaving the solid behind.
Why the other options are wrong
- (A) Dissolved salt does not settle at the bottom of water, however deep it is. The salt is left only when the water has evaporated.
- (B) Dissolved salt cannot be blown away while it is in the water. What matters is how fast the water evaporates, and the deep glass is slower.
- (C) Steel does not soak up water. The water leaves the thali by evaporating into the air, not by going into the metal.
