(i) Only the dull steel ball will stick to the magnet. Steel balls in a maze can even be moved with a magnet kept below the cardboard tray. The glass marble and the plastic button will not stick, because glass and plastic are non-magnetic materials.
(ii) No, Jatin's rule is wrong. The two shiny things were not attracted, while the dull steel ball was. Whether a thing is shiny or hard does not decide it; its material does. The correct rule is: a magnet attracts only magnetic materials, such as iron, nickel and cobalt and some of their combinations with other metals. Materials that are not attracted towards a magnet are non-magnetic materials.