No, Tara is not right. She has made a rectangle.
As in the Play with Circles activity, joining the four ends of two diameters always gives a rectangle: its opposite sides are equal and all four corners are right angles.
Her diameters do not cross at a quarter turn, so the rectangle is not a square: two sides that are next to each other have different lengths.
A kite needs two pairs of equal sides that are next to each other. In Tara's rectangle the equal sides are opposite each other, and the sides next to each other are not equal. So it is not a kite. (Only if the diameters crossed at a quarter turn would she get a square, and a square is also a kite.)