A boat is being pulled in towards a jetty by a rope tied to its bow.
Question 141 markMCQMedium
A boat is being pulled in towards a jetty by a rope tied to its bow. The rope passes through a ring fixed on the jetty 6 m vertically above the level of the bow, and a winch on the jetty pulls the rope in at a steady 2 m/s.
At the instant when 10 m of rope lies between the ring and the bow, the speed at which the boat is approaching the jetty is
Select your answer
(A) 2 m/s
(B) 2.5 m/s
Correct answer
(C) 1.6 m/s
(D) 1.2 m/s
Option (B) is correct.
Let x m be the horizontal distance of the bow from the jetty wall and L m the length of rope between the ring and the bow. The rope, the 6 m vertical drop and x form a right triangle, so
L2=x2+36
Differentiate both sides with respect to time t:
2LdtdL=2xdtdx⟹dtdx=xL⋅dtdL
The rope is being shortened, so dtdL=−2 m/s. When L=10, x=100−36=8. Hence
dtdx=810×(−2)=−2.5 m/s
The negative sign means x is decreasing: the boat approaches the jetty at 2.5 m/s.
Why the other options are wrong.
(A) 2 m/s assumes the boat moves exactly as fast as the rope is reeled in. The rope is slanted, so only part of the boat's motion shortens it; the boat must move faster than the rope.
(C) 1.6 m/s is 108×2: the ratio xL has been turned upside down to Lx.
(D) 1.2 m/s is 106×2: it uses the vertical side 6 in place of x, which does not come from differentiating L2=x2+36 at all.
Note: since xL>1 and grows as x shrinks, the boat speeds up as it nears the jetty even though the winch turns at a steady rate.