A solid ball of radius R fits snugly inside a hollow right circular cone, touching the base of the cone and touching…
Question 285 marksHard
A solid ball of radius R fits snugly inside a hollow right circular cone, touching the base of the cone and touching its curved surface all the way round. The figure shows the cross-section through the axis: the cone has vertex V, height VM=h and base radius MB=r; the ball has centre O on VM and touches VB at T.
(i) Show that r2=h−2RR2h, where h>2R.
(ii) Hence show that the volume of the cone is least when h=4R, and that this least volume is twice the volume of the ball.
(iii) For the cone of least volume, find the base radius r in terms of R and the sine of the semi-vertical angle.
Concept. Relate r to h by similar triangles, write the cone's volume as a function of h alone, and use the first derivative test on its domain h>2R.
Given: ball of radius R touching the base and the curved surface; cone height h, base radius r.
To find: the relation between r and h, the least volume, and the shape of that cone.
Step 1 — Similar triangles (part (i)). Since the ball touches the base at M, OM=R and so VO=h−R. The radius OT is perpendicular to the tangent VB, and OT=R. Triangles VTO and VMB are both right-angled (at T and at M) and share the angle at V, so they are similar:
VOOT=VBMB⟹h−RR=h2+r2r
Squaring and cross-multiplying:
R2(h2+r2)=r2(h−R)2⟹R2h2=r2[(h−R)2−R2]=r2(h2−2hR)
Dividing by h(h−2R), which is positive because the vertex lies above the top of the ball (h>2R),
Step 4 — First derivative test. For 2R<h<4R, h−4R<0 so V′(h)<0; for h>4R, V′(h)>0. So V decreases and then increases: h=4R gives the least volume over the whole domain.
Step 5 — The least volume.
V(4R)=3πR2⋅2R16R2=38πR3=2×34πR3
which is twice the volume of the ball. This completes part (ii).
Step 6 — Shape of that cone (part (iii)).
r2=4R−2RR2(4R)=2R2⟹r=2R
If α is the semi-vertical angle, then in triangle VTO,
sinα=VOOT=4R−RR=31
Answer: (i) r2=h−2RR2h. (ii) The volume is least when h=4R, and the least volume is 38πR3, twice the ball's volume. (iii) r=2R and sinα=31.
Note: do not confuse this with the largest cone inscribed in a sphere (Miscellaneous Exercise, Q12), whose altitude is 34 of the radius. Here the cone is outside the ball, and we look for the least volume.