Two events A and B are independent if and only if P(A∩B)=P(A)P(B).
Given: a token drawn at random, all numbers equally likely; A: multiple of 2, B: multiple of 5. To find: whether P(A∩B)=P(A)P(B) for tokens 1–20 and for tokens 1–25.
Step 1 — tokens 1 to 20. A={2,4,…,20} has 10 numbers, B={5,10,15,20} has 4 numbers, and A∩B={10,20} has 2 numbers. So
P(A)=2010=21,P(B)=204=51,P(A∩B)=202=101
Since P(A)P(B)=21×51=101=P(A∩B), the events A and B are independent.
Step 2 — tokens 1 to 25. Now A={2,4,…,24} has 12 numbers, B={5,10,15,20,25} has 5 numbers, and A∩B={10,20} still has 2 numbers:
P(A)=2512,P(B)=255=51,P(A∩B)=252
Here P(A)P(B)=2512×51=12512, while P(A∩B)=252=12510. These are not equal, so A and B are not independent.
Answer: (i) independent, since P(A∩B)=101=P(A)P(B); (ii) no, since 252=12512.
Note: The events are described by the same words in both cases, but independence is a statement about probabilities, so it depends on the sample space. Also, A and B are independent in (i) even though they share outcomes; independent events are not the same as mutually exclusive events.