On the set of real numbers, define
Check whether is reflexive, symmetric and transitive. Prove each property that holds, and give a counterexample for each property that fails.
Confirming your payment
Practice Questions · Question 22 of 30
On the set of real numbers, define
Check whether is reflexive, symmetric and transitive. Prove each property that holds, and give a counterexample for each property that fails.
Reflexive? We need for every real . This fails for negative . Take : here , and is false. So , and is not reflexive.
(The condition does hold for , since then . But one failing value is enough.)
Symmetric? Take and . Then , so . But is false, so . is not symmetric.
Transitive? Suppose and , so that
The second inequality gives . So is not negative, and . The first inequality now reads . Putting the two together,
so , that is, . is transitive.
Conclusion. is transitive, but it is neither reflexive nor symmetric.

In the figure, is the shaded wedge. The line lies inside it only for , which is why reflexivity fails for negative .