Option (D) is correct.
Assertion (A) — is P transitive?
Transitivity requires that whenever (a,b)∈P and (b,c)∈P, the pair (a,c) is also in P. Take
(4,2)∈Pand(2,4)∈P
Transitivity would then force (4,4)∈P, but (4,4)∈/P. One failing chain is enough, so P is not transitive and Assertion (A) is false.
Reason (R) — does P contain such a subset?
Take a=0, b=2, c=4. Then
(0,2)∈P,(2,4)∈P,(0,4)∈P
All three pairs are present, so Reason (R) is true.
Why (R) does not rescue (A). Containing one chain that closes up is not transitivity; transitivity demands that every chain closes up. Reason (R) is a statement about a single triple, while the Assertion is a statement about all of them — which is exactly why (A) can be false while (R) is true.
Since (A) is false and (R) is true, the answer is (D).
Why the other options are wrong
- Options (A) and (B) are wrong: both need Assertion (A) to be true, but (4,2)∈P and (2,4)∈P while (4,4)∈/P, so P is not transitive.
- Option (C) is wrong: it says (A) is true and (R) is false, the exact reverse of the truth.
