(i) Testing the three properties
Reflexive. Take any person x∈U. The time difference between x's zone and itself is 0 hours, not 6 hours. So (x,x)∈/R, and this fails for every x. Hence R is not reflexive.
Symmetric. Suppose (x,y)∈R, so the difference between the zones of x and y is 6 hours. A time difference between two zones is the same measured either way round, so the difference between the zones of y and x is also 6 hours. Therefore
(x,y)∈R ⇒ (y,x)∈R
and R is symmetric.
Transitive. Here a single counterexample settles it. Suppose
- x lives in the zone UTC+0,
- y lives in the zone UTC+6,
- z lives in the zone UTC+12.
Then the difference between x and y is 6 hours, so (x,y)∈R, and the difference between y and z is 6 hours, so (y,z)∈R. But the difference between x and z is
12−0=12 hours=6 hours
so (x,z)∈/R. Transitivity fails for this triple, and that is enough: R is not transitive.
(In general, if y is 6 hours from both x and z, then x and z are either in the same zone — a difference of 0 — or 12 hours apart. Neither is 6, so in fact transitivity fails for every such triple with x=z.)
(ii) Is R an equivalence relation?
An equivalence relation must be reflexive, symmetric and transitive. R is symmetric, but it is neither reflexive nor transitive. Hence R is not an equivalence relation.
