Begin by comparing the ingredient lists pair by pair, since every part rests on this table:
| Pair | Common ingredient | In R? |
|---|
| T1,T2 | dal | yes |
| T1,T3 | none | no |
| T1,T4 | rice | yes |
| T1,T5 | rice | yes |
| T2,T3 | spinach | yes |
| T2,T4 | none | no |
| T2,T5 | none | no |
| T3,T4 | curd | yes |
| T3,T5 | none | no |
| T4,T5 | rice | yes |
(a) The related pairs of distinct trays are
{T1,T2},{T1,T4},{T1,T5},{T2,T3},{T3,T4},{T4,T5}
six in all. The four unrelated pairs are
{T1,T3},{T2,T4},{T2,T5},{T3,T5}
(b) Reflexive. Each tray has at least one ingredient, and every ingredient of Ti is of course an ingredient of Ti. So Ti and Ti have an ingredient in common and (Ti,Ti)∈R for all five trays.
Symmetric. The defining condition is that the two ingredient lists share a member, and "Ti and Tj share an ingredient" says exactly the same thing as "Tj and Ti share an ingredient" — the condition does not distinguish the two trays. Hence (Ti,Tj)∈R⇒(Tj,Ti)∈R.
(c) Take the triple T1,T2,T3. From the table,
(T1,T2)∈R(they share dal),(T2,T3)∈R(they share spinach)
Transitivity would force (T1,T3)∈R. But T1={rice, dal} and T3={spinach, curd} have nothing in common, so (T1,T3)∈/R. The missing pair is (T1,T3), and R is therefore not transitive.
The reason is worth noticing: T1 and T3 are joined only through T2, and they reach T2 by different ingredients — dal on one side, spinach on the other. A shared ingredient does not carry across a middle tray.
(d) Count in two pieces.
Pairs with distinct entries: part (a) found 6 related unordered pairs. By symmetry each gives 2 ordered pairs, contributing 6×2=12.
Pairs with equal entries: by reflexivity all 5 pairs (Ti,Ti) lie in R.
∣R∣=12+5=17

(e) The new tray is T6={curd}. Comparing it with the others: it shares curd with T3 and with T4, and has nothing in common with T1, T2 or T5.
Transitivity. Adding a tray cannot repair the failure already found — T1,T2,T3 are all still present and (T1,T3) is still absent. So R is still not transitive.
The new count. The related unordered pairs of distinct trays are the original 6 together with {T3,T6} and {T4,T6}, giving 8. There are now 6 trays, so 6 reflexive pairs:
∣R∣=8×2+6=22