Two unlabelled bottles contain aniline and phenol. Both are colourless liquids or low-melting solids when pure, and both are only partly soluble in water. Which test distinguishes them?
Practice Questions · Question 2 of 30
Two unlabelled bottles contain aniline and phenol.
(A) Adding bromine water to each and looking for a white precipitate
(B) Adding aqueous sodium hydrogencarbonate to each and looking for effervescence
(C) Adding ethanolic silver nitrate to each and looking for a precipitate
- Correct answer
(D) Shaking each separately with dilute HCl and with dilute NaOH, and noting in which it dissolves
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: Aniline is a base (lone pair on N) and phenol is a weak acid (O–H). Each one dissolves only in the reagent it can react with, because the product is an ionic salt that is soluble in water.
Aniline dissolves in dilute HCl, forming anilinium chloride, but stays undissolved in dilute NaOH:
Phenol dissolves in dilute NaOH, forming sodium phenoxide, but stays undissolved in dilute HCl:

So the pattern "dissolves in acid, not in alkali" identifies aniline, and "dissolves in alkali, not in acid" identifies phenol.
- (A) is wrong: both give a white precipitate. The and groups both activate the ring strongly, so aniline gives 2,4,6-tribromoaniline and phenol gives 2,4,6-tribromophenol ().
- (B) is wrong: neither gives . Aniline is a base, and phenol is too weak an acid to decompose sodium hydrogencarbonate (only carboxylic acids do).
- (C) is wrong: silver nitrate precipitates halide ions. Neither compound contains a halogen, so neither gives a precipitate.
