(a) Methanoic acid, HCOOH, is written as H−CO−OH: its carbon carries a hydrogen atom and a C=O group, exactly like the −CHO group of an aldehyde. So methanoic acid is also oxidised by Tollens' reagent and also gives a silver mirror. Tollens' reagent alone would pick out two bottles, methanoic acid and ethanal, and could not tell which one is the aldehyde.
(b) Test 1: sodium hydrogencarbonate. Add a little of each liquid to aqueous NaHCO3. Both acids give brisk effervescence of CO2; ethanal, which is not an acid, gives none.
HCOOH+NaHCO3→HCOONa+H2O+CO2↑
CH3COOH+NaHCO3→CH3COONa+H2O+CO2↑
Test 2: Tollens' reagent. Warm each liquid with Tollens' reagent. Methanoic acid and ethanal give a silver mirror; ethanoic acid does not, because it has no H on the carbonyl carbon. Methanoic acid is oxidised all the way to carbonate:
HCOOH+2[Ag(NH3)2]++4OH−→CO32−+2Ag↓+3H2O+4NH3
CH3CHO+2[Ag(NH3)2]++3OH−→CH3COO−+2Ag↓+2H2O+4NH3
Reading the two results together:
| Compound | NaHCO3 | Tollens' reagent | Conclusion |
|---|
| Methanoic acid | effervescence | silver mirror | acid and reducing |
| Ethanoic acid | effervescence | no change | acid, not reducing |
| Ethanal | no change | silver mirror | reducing, not an acid |
Each bottle gives a different pair of results, so the two tests together identify all three.
