NCERT notes that an alkyl halide can be converted into a carboxylic acid having one more carbon atom either through a…
Question 305 marksMedium
NCERT notes that an alkyl halide can be converted into a carboxylic acid having one more carbon atom either through a nitrile or through a Grignard reagent.
(a) Show both routes for converting 1-bromobutane into pentanoic acid. Write balanced equations with reagents and conditions, and name every intermediate. [3]
(b) Only one of the two routes works well for each of the following conversions. State which route you would use in each case and explain why the other route fails. [2]
(i) 2-Bromo-2-methylpropane, (CH3)3CBr, to 2,2-dimethylpropanoic acid, (CH3)3CCOOH
(ii) 2-Bromoethanol, HOCH2CH2Br, to 3-hydroxypropanoic acid, HOCH2CH2COOH
(a) Route 1: through the nitrile. 1-Bromobutane is heated with ethanolic potassium cyanide. The cyanide ion replaces bromide by an SN2 reaction, adding one carbon atom:
Intermediate: pentanenitrile. It is hydrolysed by heating with dilute acid (through the amide) to the acid:
CH3(CH2)3CN+2H2O+H+ΔCH3(CH2)3COOH+NH4+
Route 2: through the Grignard reagent. 1-Bromobutane reacts with magnesium in dry ether to give butylmagnesium bromide:
CH3(CH2)3Br+Mgdry etherCH3(CH2)3MgBr
The Grignard reagent is poured onto dry ice. The nucleophilic butyl group adds to the carbon of CO2, giving the magnesium salt of the acid (bromomagnesium pentanoate), which is then acidified:
In both routes the new carbon comes from the reagent (CN− or CO2), so the four-carbon halide gives the five-carbon acid, pentanoic acid.
(b) (i) Use the Grignard route. 2-Bromo-2-methylpropane is a tertiary halide. The crowded carbon cannot be attacked from the back, so the SN2 reaction with cyanide does not occur. Instead the cyanide ion acts as a base and removes a β-hydrogen, so the main product is the alkene 2-methylpropene, not the nitrile:
(CH3)3CBr+CN−→(CH3)2C=CH2+HCN+Br−
A tertiary halide forms a Grignard reagent without difficulty, and this reagent adds to CO2:
(ii) Use the nitrile route. A Grignard reagent is a very strong base. The molecule also contains an acidic O–H hydrogen, so as soon as any C–Mg bond forms it is protonated by an –OH group, giving a C–H bond instead; the reagent is destroyed and cannot react with CO2. The cyanide route is not affected by the –OH group, because SN2 substitution at the primary CH2Br carbon goes normally: