A student is given three colourless liquids: propanal, propanone and propanoic acid. The student first adds sodium hydrogen carbonate solution to each sample, and then warms each of the two samples that showed no change in this test with Tollens' reagent. Which observation correctly identifies the compounds?
Practice Questions · Question 1 of 30
A student is given three colourless liquids: propanal, propanone and propanoic acid.
Question 11 markMCQMedium
Select your answer
(A) Propanal releases ; propanone gives a silver mirror
(B) Propanone releases ; propanoic acid gives a silver mirror
(C) Propanoic acid releases ; propanone gives a silver mirror
- Correct answer
(D) Propanoic acid releases ; propanal gives a silver mirror
Option (D) is correct.
Explanation: The two tests pick out the three functional groups one at a time.
- Sodium hydrogen carbonate test (for ): a carboxylic acid is a stronger acid than carbonic acid, so it decomposes with brisk effervescence of . Only propanoic acid reacts:
- Tollens' test (for ): on warming, an aldehyde reduces ammoniacal silver nitrate to metallic silver, which coats the tube as a bright silver mirror. The aldehyde is oxidised to its carboxylate ion:
- Propanone is a ketone. It has no acidic group and no aldehydic H, so it gives neither result.

- (A) is wrong: propanal is not acidic enough to release , and a ketone does not reduce Tollens' reagent.
- (B) is wrong: propanone does not react with , and propanoic acid is already fully oxidised, so it cannot reduce .
- (C) is wrong: the gas from a carboxylic acid and is , not ( is given with active metals such as Na), and propanone does not give a silver mirror.
