Both and have a coordination number of 4, yet one is tetrahedral and the other is square planar. Using valence bond theory, explain the difference, and state which of the two is coloured and which is paramagnetic (give its spin-only magnetic moment). (Zn, ; Cu, )
Practice Questions · Question 9 of 30
Both [Zn(NH₃)₄]²+ and [Cu(NH₃)₄]²+ have a coordination number of 4, yet one is tetrahedral and the other is square…
In both ions the metal is : .
. Zinc is , so is . All five orbitals are full, so no orbital can be used. The four molecules donate their lone pairs into the empty and three orbitals:
Every electron is paired (), so the ion is diamagnetic, and with a completely filled set no – transition is possible, so it is colourless.
. Copper is , so is , with one unpaired electron. In the valence bond picture this electron is promoted to a orbital, which frees one orbital. That orbital, the orbital and two orbitals accept the four ligand pairs:

The ion still has one unpaired electron ():
So is paramagnetic (1.73 BM), and because its set is incomplete (), a – transition can absorb visible light: it is coloured (deep blue).
Conclusion. The coordination number alone does not fix the shape. () has no vacant orbital and must use (tetrahedral), while () makes a orbital available and uses (square planar).
