(a) The ethical argument. NCERT: "Philosophically or spiritually, we need to realise that every species has an intrinsic value, even if it may not be of current or any economic value to us. We have a moral duty to care for their well-being". In a sacred grove, all the trees and wildlife are venerated and protected because of spiritual belief, not because they earn money or provide a service. That is the ethical argument in practice.
(b) The narrowly utilitarian argument values species for "direct economic benefits", such as food, firewood, fibre, industrial products and medicines. Under that approach, only species with a known use would be protected. A sacred grove protects every plant, useful or not. As a result, NCERT notes, "In Meghalaya, the sacred groves are the last refuges for a large number of rare and threatened plants." Many of these plants survived only because nobody had to prove that they were worth money.
| Argument | Which species it protects |
|---|
| narrowly utilitarian | only those with direct economic uses |
| ethical (as in sacred groves) | all species, whatever their value to us |
