Reason 1: ex situ methods can store only species we know about. A seed or gamete can be collected only from a species that has been found and named. If we accept Robert May's estimate, only about 22 per cent of the earth's species have been recorded so far, and NCERT warns that "a large fraction of these species faces the threat of becoming extinct even before we discover them." Clearing the forest would destroy all its undiscovered species. The only way to keep them is to keep their habitat.
Reason 2: in situ conservation protects the whole ecosystem at every level; stored seeds and gametes do not. NCERT: "When we conserve and protect the whole ecosystem, its biodiversity at all levels is protected - we save the entire forest to save the tiger." A freezer of gametes holds no forest ecosystem. It does not keep the ecosystem services the forest provides, or the partner species that threatened species depend on, such as pollinators, the loss of which leads to co-extinction.
| What is kept | Ex situ store | Protected forest (in situ) |
|---|
| known threatened species | yes | yes |
| species not yet discovered | no | yes |
| the ecosystem and its services | no | yes |
| partner species and interactions | no | yes |
Ex situ methods are the right choice for organisms that need "urgent measures" to save them from extinction, but they add to in situ protection. They cannot replace it.
